South Asia and LGBT Legislation {Social Justice Sunday}

June 29, 2014 - by Nadya

For this first National Pride Month we had a lot to celebrate:

  • Last June DOMA was struck down
  • 10 more states have legalized gay marriage (I see you Pennsylvania, Illinois, Oregon, Hawaii, Delaware, Rhode Island, Minnesota, New Jersey, California (again), and New Mexico) bringing the grand total to 19 states
  • Michael Sam, the first out player, got drafted to the NFL
  • Laverne Cox, trans goddess, appeared on the cover of Time magazine
  • Medicare now covers trans surgeries
  • Title IX now extends to trans students
  • And Harvey Milk has finally been immortalized on a US postal stamp!

But for all the progress we have made in the United States for LGBT rights, the Motherland remains painfully behind.  In India, same-sex relationships, considered an 'Unnatural Offense,' have been illegal since 1860 under Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code and the rate of violence against the LGBT community remains  high in both Pakistan and India.

SJS.GayLaws width=

In 2009, in the landmark case Naz Foundation v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, the Delhi High Court ruled Section 377, which prohibited same-sex relationships, and all other legal prohibitions against non-commercial consensual adult same-sex activities to be unconstitutional.  On December 11th, 2013, the Supreme Court of India upheld the primacy of section 377 and overturned this ruling.  One step forward and one step back.

Many many other commentators  have said it before, but it's worth saying again - before the British came, India had no conception of anti-gay culture let alone legislation.  Vedic statues and writing in the Kama Sutra all depict same-sex relationships as normal and place them alongside heterosexual relationships.  But when the conservative (read: unmoving, uptight, and close-minded) Victorians came, they established the same destructive laws they had back home.  They even placed their anti-LGBT laws alongside anti-bestiality laws in Section 377, as though they're the same thing.

The question remains then why hasn't the Indian law prohibiting same-sex relationships changed since 1860? You would think after 150 years, something would need updating.  The major opponents to gay rights in India belong to conservative Hindu groups (a major irony since the relationship between Vishnu and Shiva wasn't always so brotherly and Shiva is often described as part man and part woman).

indian gay population width=

Daily, Desis in the Motherland suffer tremendously for their gender identity and their sexual orientation.  The focus on religion and family in both India and Pakistan usually relegates non-gender conforming and gay Desis to undesirable parts of the social hierarchy - unmarried men become targets for village persecution, women are sometimes forced into marriage, and those recognized as the 'third gender' (trans people) are often ousted from their homes.

In other parts of South Asia, LGBT people don't fair too much better.  With the exception of Nepal which has recognized same-sex relationships, has ruled that anti-discrimination laws apply to homosexual people, and allows gays to serve openly in its military, gay rights are practically nonexistent in the region.  In South Asia, same-sex relationships can incur lifetime imprisonment and fines and gay marriage is a far distant dream.  Trans rights are a little better as Bangladesh, alongside India, Pakistan, and Nepal, also recognizes the existence of the 'third gender.'


via National Geographic

Trans rights in South Asia are developing slowly.  For many years, Hijras (the male to female transgenders who have been inherent to South Asian culture for centuries) were barred from receiving recognition by the state and did not have access to safe medical facilities.  Their social marginalization forced them into sex work and other dangerous activities.  According to the International Aids Society, 45-50% of Hijras in India suffer from HIV/AIDS.

In April of this year, the Supreme Court of India determined Hijras to be a 'backwards class' and therefore able to receive the social and economic benefits of the affirmative action programs that worked to support backwards classes and scheduled castes.  Pakistan preceded India's ruling with their own in 2009 which determined that Hijras, as citizens of the state, were entitled to protection under Pakistani law.  Pakistan's chief justice Iftikhar Chaudhry championed the cause of Pakistan's trans community and orchestrated major extensions of their rights during his term.

The lives of Hijras in South Asia are slowly improving, though not at a pace any of us have patience for.  Gay people of all genders are also slowly winning what they deserve - the unrest after the Supreme Court of India overturned the Naz ruling was palpable and I envision Section 377 will be contested again soon enough.

The world is changing its mind about lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people (maybe soon it will create room for questioning, intersex, and asexual/aromantic people as well).  To toast our inevitable future, I leave you with a hilarious video of Bollywood heartthrob Imran Khan showing you just how ridiculous Indian homophobia is:

To the long march forward!

Related posts


Navratri: The 9 Avatars of Durga & 9 Colors to Wear This Festive Week

Navratri begins the festive month leading up to Dussera and the Diwali. Navratri means "nine nights" (nava - 9; ratri - night). Hindus celebrate the divine mother goddess Durga [...]

Pakistani Wedding Dresses | Irfan Ahson Photos 03

51 Inspirational Red Pakistani Bridal Outfits by {Irfan Ahson Photography}

We have a photo overload for you! Thanks to the insanely talented and fabulous Irfan bhai, a photographer in Pakistan, we are able to share his amazing bridal photography.


12 Favorite Holiday Scents & Candles

Happy holidays, lovely readers! Shriya here with some extra reasons to celebrate this festive season: scents! There's so many tingling senses during this happy time of year: the sounds of bells and carols, the kisses and hugs of loved ones, the tastes of yummy seasonal dishes...and of course, the aroma of wintery, holiday joy.

Tanishq Mawari Bride Jewelry

The Essential Guide to Indian Jewelry

The wide world of Indian wedding planning is, well, wide.  One of the most important elements (as far as the bride and her mother are concerned) is the bridal jewelry.  There are so many options, and in our modern age brides have access to basically all of them.  So where do you start?

Sonia Azhaar - Pakistan Bridal Week 2013 3

Sonia Azhar's Divine Unison {L’Oreal Pakistan Bridal Fashion Week 2013}

Sonia Azhar, a big name in bridal ware, has made a rather brave move  with her new line 'Divine Unison.'  Maybe I'm just coming off of Halloween but it feels like she's just taped fairy wings to the back of outfits we've all seen before.  Her combination of religious iconography with South Asian bridal wear is, sadly, not a match made in heaven.

Mahira Dastoor - Gifts

Mahira Dastoor - Marwari Gifting Ritual

The Marwaris are known for their lavish and intricate weddings. One of the prewedding events is the Mahira Dastor. Because the cost of the wedding run high, the maternal uncles on [...]